Build vs. Buy: The Real Cost of DIY Azure Key Vault Monitoring

"We'll just write a quick PowerShell script."

Famous last words in DevOps. What starts as a Friday afternoon project to scan Azure Key Vault expirations inevitably becomes a sprawling, undocumented system that breaks at 2 AM and that only one person understands.

We've seen this pattern dozens of times. A team recognizes they need Key Vault expiration monitoring, estimates it'll take a few days to build, and six months later they're still maintaining it — or worse, they've abandoned it and are back to spreadsheets.

Let's break down what a complete DIY monitoring solution actually requires, calculate the true cost, and help you make an informed build-vs-buy decision.

The "Quick Script" Trap

The initial scope always seems manageable:

1. Query Azure Key Vault for secrets, certificates, and keys
2. Check expiration dates
3. Send an email if something expires soon

A senior engineer could prototype this in an afternoon. So what's the problem?

The problem is that a prototype isn't a product. The gap between "works on my machine" and "reliable production monitoring" is where projects go to die.

What a Complete Solution Actually Requires

Let's walk through the components you'll need to build — not for a demo, but for something you can actually rely on.

1. Multi-Subscription Scanning

Most organizations have multiple Azure subscriptions. Your script needs to:

• Authenticate across subscriptions (managed identity? service principal?)
• Handle subscriptions being added or removed
• Respect RBAC permissions per subscription
• Deal with rate limiting from Azure APIs
• Retry failed scans gracefully

Estimated effort: 2-3 days for initial implementation, ongoing maintenance as subscriptions change.

2. Team-Based Alert Routing

Sending all alerts to one email address doesn't scale. You need:

• A mapping of vaults/subscriptions to team owners
• Logic to route alerts to the right people
• Escalation paths when primary contacts don't respond
• A way to update ownership without code changes
• Handling for orphaned vaults with no clear owner

Estimated effort: 3-5 days, plus ongoing updates as teams change.

3. A Dashboard for Visibility

Command-line output isn't useful for leadership or auditors. You need:

• A web UI showing all monitored items
• Filtering by subscription, vault, type, urgency
• Visual timeline of upcoming expirations
• Quick links to Azure portal for remediation
• Mobile-friendly for on-call engineers

Estimated effort: 2-4 weeks for a basic dashboard, ongoing feature requests.

4. Audit Logging for Compliance

Auditors will ask: "How do you know your monitoring is working?" You need:

• Logs of every scan with timestamps
• Records of alerts sent and to whom
• History of items that expired (and whether you were warned)
• Exportable reports in auditor-friendly formats
• Retention policies that meet compliance requirements

Estimated effort: 1-2 weeks, plus storage costs and retention management.

5. Monitoring the Monitor

What happens when your monitoring script fails? You need:

• Health checks for the scanning process
• Alerts when scans don't run
• Dashboards showing scan success/failure rates
• Runbooks for common failure modes
• Someone on-call for the monitoring system itself

Estimated effort: 1 week initial, plus ongoing on-call rotation.

6. Notification Integrations

Email isn't enough. Teams want alerts in:

• Microsoft Teams channels
• Slack
• PagerDuty for critical items
• ServiceNow for ticket creation
• Custom webhooks for internal tools

Estimated effort: 2-5 days per integration, ongoing maintenance as APIs change.

Calculating the True Cost

Let's put real numbers to this. We'll use conservative estimates.

Initial Development

At $800/day for a senior engineer:

• Multi-subscription scanning — 3 days — $2,400
• Team-based routing — 4 days — $3,200
• Basic dashboard — 15 days — $12,000
• Audit logging — 8 days — $6,400
• Monitoring the monitor — 5 days — $4,000
• Two integrations (Teams + email) — 4 days — $3,200
• Testing and documentation — 5 days — $4,000

Total Initial Build: 44 days — $35,200

Ongoing Maintenance (Annual)

At $100/hour for maintenance work:

• Bug fixes and updates — 40 hrs — $4,000
• Azure API changes — 16 hrs — $1,600
• New subscription onboarding — 20 hrs — $2,000
• Team ownership updates — 24 hrs — $2,400
• Compliance report requests — 16 hrs — $1,600
• On-call for monitoring system — 40 hrs — $4,000
• Feature requests — 30 hrs — $3,000

Total Annual Maintenance: 186 hours — $18,600

Three-Year Total Cost of Ownership

• Year 1: $35,200 (build) + $18,600 (maintain) = $53,800
• Year 2: $18,600
• Year 3: $18,600
• Three-Year Total: $91,000

And this assumes everything goes smoothly — no major refactors, no engineer turnover requiring knowledge transfer, no security incidents requiring urgent patches.

The Hidden Costs Nobody Mentions

Beyond the direct engineering costs, DIY solutions carry hidden burdens:

Opportunity Cost

Those 44 engineering days could have been spent on:

• Features that drive revenue
• Reducing technical debt elsewhere
• Projects with actual business differentiation

Key Vault monitoring is infrastructure. It doesn't make your product better or your company more competitive. It just keeps the lights on.

Bus Factor Risk

Who maintains your monitoring script? One person? Two?

When that engineer leaves (and they will), you face:

• Knowledge transfer scramble
• Undocumented edge cases
• Potential rewrites by new team members

We've talked to companies running on monitoring scripts written by engineers who left three years ago. Nobody wants to touch them. Nobody fully understands them. They just pray they keep working.

Silent Failures

The scariest DIY monitoring failures are the ones you don't notice. Your script stopped running two weeks ago, but nobody knew until an expired certificate took down production.

Commercial solutions have entire teams ensuring reliability. Your weekend project doesn't.

When DIY Actually Makes Sense

To be fair, building your own solution can be the right choice in specific situations:

• Very small scale: Under 20 secrets across 1-2 subscriptions
• Learning exercise: Your team wants hands-on Azure experience
• Extreme customization: Requirements so unique no product fits
• Zero budget: Literally no money for tooling (but consider: is your time free?)

If none of these apply, you're probably better off buying.

When to Buy

Consider purchasing a solution when:

• You have 50+ secrets across multiple subscriptions
• Multiple teams need visibility and routing
• Compliance requirements demand audit trails
• Engineering time is valuable and better spent elsewhere
• You need reliability, not a side project

The VaultGuard360 Comparison

For context, here's what VaultGuard360 costs:

• Standard (25 items) — $299/month — $3,588/year
• Professional (500 items) — $799/month — $9,588/year
• Enterprise (unlimited) — Custom pricing

Three-year cost for Professional tier: $28,764

Compare that to our DIY estimate of $91,000 — and VaultGuard360 includes:

• Multi-subscription dashboard out of the box
• Team-based alert routing
• Audit-ready compliance reports
• Email, Teams, Slack, webhook integrations
• Zero maintenance burden
• Professional support
• Runs entirely in your Azure tenant (no data exfiltration)

Making the Decision

Here's a simple framework:

Build if:

• You have fewer than 20 secrets total
• You have engineering capacity with nothing higher-priority
• You want full control over every aspect
• You're comfortable with ongoing maintenance

Buy if:

• You have 50+ secrets across multiple subscriptions
• Engineering time is better spent on core product
• You need audit trails and compliance reports
• You want something that just works

The Bottom Line

The "quick script" for Key Vault monitoring is a trap. What seems like a small project inevitably grows into a maintenance burden that costs far more than purchasing a purpose-built solution.

We built VaultGuard360 specifically so DevOps teams don't have to solve this problem themselves. It deploys in under 30 minutes, runs in your Azure tenant, and costs a fraction of what you'd spend building and maintaining your own solution.

Your engineers have better things to do than babysit a monitoring script. Let them focus on what actually differentiates your business.

---

Ready to stop maintaining monitoring scripts? Explore VaultGuard360 or see pricing to get started with proactive Key Vault expiration monitoring.